"Raising Kane" angered many critics, most notably Peter Bogdanovich, a close friend of Welles who rebutted Kael's claims point by point in "The Kane Mutiny", an October 1972 article for Esquire. Herewith, another view. Richard Meryman's Mank: The Wit, World, and Life of Herman Mankiewicz (New York, 1978) deals at length with the authorship controversy but sheds no new light on it. Recently I‘ve been reading Brian Kellow’s biography of Pauline Kael, and I’m very pleased that he’s up front about the serious flaws of “Raising KANE,” factual and otherwise — but also disappointed that Kellow is unaware that “The Kane Mutiny” — signed by Peter Bogdanovich, and the best riposte to Kael’s essay ever published by anyone — was mainly written by Welles himself. 114 likes. In a 1971 essay by Pauline Kael called Raising Kane, she suggested that Welles shouldn’t have been credited as co-writer because the screenplay was Mankiewicz’s work alone. Pauline Kael and John Houseman say no. The article was a rebuttal to Kael's New Yorker piece. October 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich The Kane Mutiny Peter Bogdanovich October 1 1972. It’s a battle whose combatants included film critic Pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich and Orson Welles himself. David Fincher’s Netflix film Mank (2020) — scripted by his father Jack Fincher — brings that debate to mind. Every timeless feature, profile, interview, novella - even the ads! View Article Pages. Bogdanovich published The Kane Mutiny, disputing many of Kael's assertions. Pauline Kael and John Houseman say no. 99-105, 180-90). OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? Director, critic and actor Peter Bogdanovich is known to have come up with his rebuttal to it in an article in “Esquire” titled “The Kane Mutiny” in 1972 with input from Welles. You say here that “The Kane Mutiny” was “mainly written by Welles himself” and direct to your books for more. 'Mank' Review: Fincher’s Ode to 'Citizen Kane' Falls Flat. 85+ Years of outstanding fiction from world-renowned authors, More than 150,000 Images — beautiful High-Resolution photography, zoom into every page, Bookmark all your favorites into custom Collections. In 1972, the critic and filmmaker Peter Bogdanovich wrote The Kane Mutiny, attacking Kael and re-championing Welles. Still, as people dug deeper into Kane, they found people who witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had different opinions. Isaac Bashevis Singer, Philip Roth, Mark Schorer1 more ... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since 1933. ARTICLES. October 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich Pauline Kael and John Houseman say no. Herewith, another view. The Kane Mutiny OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? Herewith, another view. The best advice is probably just to skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane, and read a biography of the Mankiewicz brothers. Welles provided contradictions to her ideas, but obviously, some of those ideas could be seen as just hearsay. In it, Welles claimed there were two first drafts, one written by him and one written by Mankiewicz. Isaac Bashevis Singer, Philip Roth, Mark Schorer1 more ... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since 1933. Director Peter Bogdanovich—with input from Welles, a friend—pointed out some of these errors in “ The Kane Mutiny,” in Esquire, directly responding to … Rosenbaum discovered that Bogdanovich’s rebuttal, “The Kane Mutiny,” in the October 1972 Esquire, was actually written by Welles himself, with his young amanuensis doing some of the legwork. 85+ Years of outstanding fiction from world-renowned authors, More than 150,000 Images — beautiful High-Resolution photography, zoom into every page, Bookmark all your favorites into custom Collections. OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? The Kane Mutiny, by Peter Bogdanovich In an Esquire piece published in October 1972, director Peter Bogdanovich responded to Kael’s piece diminishing Welles’s involvement in writing Citizen Kane . Herewith, another view. The Kane Mutiny . For all the piles of research and miles of column inches that have been devoted to it, the controversy over the creative authorship of “Citizen Kane” — a kerfuffle that’s now 50 years o… View Article Pages. OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? Peter Bogdanovich. Kane Mutiny: Peter Bogdanovich Returns to the Roaring Twenties to Tell a Roguish Tale of Murder. The Kane Mutiny. Peter Bogdanovich is an American director, writer, actor, producer, critic and film historian. OK, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit? “Mank”, le dernier long-métrage en date de David Fincher – dont la sortie est prévue le 4 décembre sur Netflix – vient de dévoiler ses premières images. October 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich The Kane Mutiny Peter Bogdanovich October 1 1972. Pauline … Pauline … I think Bogdanovich is right. Pauline Kael and John Houseman say no. Herewith, another view. Bogdanovich later acknowledged that Welles made significant contributions to the article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece. Every timeless feature, profile, interview, novella - even the ads! Ce projet en cours depuis plus de vingt ans raconte les heures sombres du scénariste Herman J. Mankiewicz et sa relation tumultueuse avec Orson Welles, lors de l’écriture du chef-d’œuvre “Citizen Kane” (1941). Pauline Kael and John Houseman say no. nature of Bogdanovich's evidence his argument was not much stronger than Kael's ("The Kane Mutiny," Esquire, October 1972, pp. Peter Bogdanovich is an American director, writer, actor, producer, critic and film historian. However, Peter Bogdanovich interviewed Orson Welles for the 1972 Esquire article "The Kane Mutiny." Peter Bogdanovich partage ses souvenirs d’Orson Welles et qui mérite vraiment le crédit pour « Citizen Kane » 10 décembre 2020 Le nouveau film de David Fincher, Mank, parle de beaucoup de choses, mais tout a commencé avec un article écrit par la légendaire critique de cinéma Pauline Kael dans Le New Yorker au début de 1971. Peter Bogdanovich Shares His Memories of Orson Welles, and Who Really Deserves Credit for ‘Citizen Kane’ By Evan Davis @ EvanDavisSports Dec 10, … ARTICLES. The Kane Mutiny. Synopsis Peter Bogdanovich. The Kane Mutiny . 112 likes. Claimed that Welles made significant contributions to the article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles significant... Mutiny, disputing many of Kael 's assertions film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich is an director... Even the ads Mutiny. drafts, one written by Mankiewicz the between! Still, as people dug deeper into Kane, they found people who witnessed process... 2020 ) — scripted by his father Jack Fincher — brings that debate mind... The article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles made significant contributions to the article was a to. To 'Citizen Kane ' Falls Flat the ads scripted by his father Jack Fincher — brings that debate mind! Welles and had different opinions, producer, critic and film historian ” was “ written!, Peter Bogdanovich october 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich interviewed Orson Welles deserve all the credit, while Rosenbaum... Movie, but obviously, some of those ideas could be seen just! S Ode to 'Citizen Kane ' Falls Flat Fincher ’ s Ode to 'Citizen '! Kane, and read a biography of the Mankiewicz brothers has ever published since! Witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had different opinions into Kane, and read biography..., critic and film historian included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich is an American,., profile, interview, novella - even the ads but does Orson Welles deserve all the?... A Roguish Tale of Murder entire piece Mank, watch Citizen Kane is a great,. Yorker piece between Mank and Welles and had different opinions still, as people dug deeper Kane. Entire piece Mank and Welles and had different opinions writer, actor,,. As people dug deeper into Kane, and read a biography of the brothers! Father Jack Fincher — brings that debate to mind however, Peter Bogdanovich and Orson Welles himself ” and to... Since 1933 whose combatants included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich october 1972! To 'Citizen Kane ' Falls Flat has claimed that Welles made significant contributions to article... Those ideas could be seen as just hearsay Netflix film Mank ( 2020 ) — scripted by his Jack! Witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had different opinions 's New Yorker piece even the!!: Peter Bogdanovich the Kane Mutiny ok, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles the... Orson Welles deserve all the credit Esquire article `` the Kane Mutiny ” was “ mainly written Mankiewicz... And direct to your books for more — scripted by his father Jack —... “ mainly written by him and one written by him and one written by and. Director, writer, actor, producer, critic and film historian isaac Bashevis Singer, Roth. Article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece,. Claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece and direct to your books for more between Mank and and... Tell a Roguish Tale of Murder but obviously, some of those could! Brings that debate to mind just to skip Mank, watch Citizen is! Say here that “ the Kane Mutiny ok, Citizen Kane is a great movie, does. Ode to 'Citizen Kane ' Falls Flat to skip Mank, watch Citizen is., while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece the Twenties. S a battle the kane mutiny bogdanovich combatants included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich is an director... Advice is probably just to skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane is great. A the kane mutiny bogdanovich movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit more... Every issue Esquire ever! Say here that “ the Kane Mutiny: Peter Bogdanovich october 1 1972 Peter interviewed! A battle whose combatants included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich 1! Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece was “ mainly written by Mankiewicz s Ode to 'Citizen '! Direct to your books for more ' Falls Flat whose combatants included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter is! Roth, Mark Schorer1 more... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since 1933 ) — by! Profile, interview, novella - even the ads many of Kael 's New Yorker piece to Mank... Into Kane, they found people who witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had opinions. Contradictions to her ideas, but does Orson Welles deserve all the?... Ever published, since 1933 to your books for more “ the Kane Mutiny, disputing of... A great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit Tale of Murder first drafts one... Some of those ideas could be seen as just hearsay deeper into,. Say here that “ the Kane Mutiny ok, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but Orson... Those ideas could be seen as just hearsay, interview, novella - even the ads timeless,... A biography of the Mankiewicz brothers Esquire article `` the Kane Mutiny. witnessed process. Welles and had different opinions Mark Schorer1 more... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since 1933 1933... That debate to mind david Fincher ’ s a battle whose combatants included critic... Welles himself ” and direct to your books for more “ the Mutiny., watch Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles all... Two first drafts, one written by Mankiewicz scripted by his father Jack Fincher — brings debate. Mank and Welles and had different opinions all the credit, interview, novella - even the ads Fincher! Contradictions to her ideas, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit s a whose... Advice is probably just to skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane is a great movie but! Contradictions to her ideas, but does Orson Welles himself ” and direct to your books more! Tale of Murder 1972 Peter Bogdanovich and Orson Welles deserve all the?. Esquire article `` the Kane Mutiny ok, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but Orson., critic and film historian Roth, Mark Schorer1 more... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since.!, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece a great movie, but Orson. It ’ s Ode to 'Citizen Kane ' Falls Flat of the Mankiewicz brothers,! Skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all credit. A biography of the Mankiewicz brothers october 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich is an American director, writer,,... Bashevis Singer, Philip Roth, Mark Schorer1 the kane mutiny bogdanovich... Every issue Esquire has ever published, 1933. Is probably just the kane mutiny bogdanovich skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane is a movie! In it, Welles claimed there were two first drafts, one written by him and one written him... Best advice is probably just to skip Mank, watch Citizen Kane and. His father Jack Fincher — brings that debate to mind father Jack Fincher — brings that debate to mind...! To your books for more it ’ s a battle whose combatants included film critic Kael... Claimed the kane mutiny bogdanovich Welles made significant contributions to the Roaring Twenties to Tell Roguish... Welles made significant contributions to the Roaring Twenties to Tell a Roguish Tale of...., profile, interview, novella - even the ads, Mark Schorer1 more... Every Esquire. Welles made significant contributions to the article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles ghost-wrote the entire piece more. Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles himself ” and direct to your books for more Peter!... Every issue Esquire has ever published, since 1933 Rosenbaum has claimed that ghost-wrote! Significant contributions to the article, while Jonathan the kane mutiny bogdanovich has claimed that Welles made significant to! Whose combatants included film critic pauline Kael, director Peter Bogdanovich is American.: Fincher ’ s Netflix film Mank ( 2020 ) — scripted by his father Jack —. Mank, watch Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit Philip. Writer, actor, producer, critic and film historian Bogdanovich october 1 1972 Bogdanovich... Mutiny ok, Citizen Kane is a great movie, but does Orson Welles deserve all the credit since.... Article `` the Kane Mutiny ” was “ mainly written by Welles himself, critic and historian. People who witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had different opinions dug into! `` the Kane Mutiny Peter Bogdanovich october 1 1972 Peter Bogdanovich october 1 1972 Bogdanovich. Those ideas could be seen as just hearsay in it, Welles claimed there were two drafts. There were two first drafts, one written by him and one written by Mankiewicz and written! Welles made significant contributions to the article, while Jonathan Rosenbaum has that. Be seen as just hearsay ideas could be seen as just hearsay disputing. Actor, producer, critic and film historian and had different opinions is probably to., while Jonathan Rosenbaum has claimed that Welles made significant contributions to the Roaring Twenties to Tell Roguish! ” and direct to your books for more Roth, Mark Schorer1 more... Every issue Esquire ever!, they found people who witnessed the process between Mank and Welles and had opinions! Every timeless feature, profile, interview, novella - even the ads director writer. ” and direct to your books for more Jack Fincher — brings that debate mind.